Mystery/Crime Fiction

© Sandy Mitchell

James Patterson

  1. shelfmonkey


Reply   Post   Top
1.   Dec 16, 2006 8:28 AM

» shelfmonkey - Am I the only one who can't stand him?

In response to Am I the only one who can't stand him? posted by sandymae2000:


Exactly, but it's not just the short chapters (although Patterson and Brown have not exactly endeared me to that particular trick). Yes, these are works designed for ADD sufferers, but there's more to it. There's no tension, no imagination. Patterson (at least in the Cross novels I've read), switches back and forth from first-person Cross narrative to third-person psycho-killer perspective. So, we get no sense of intrigue. If it's Cross we're suppposed to care about, then let's follow him. Otherwise, it's lazy. One of the books I read (can't remember which) went on and on about how smart Cross was, and yet he didn't figure out anything, it all happened, and he just lucked into a solution. There was no mystery, no sleuthing, no triumph of investigative techniques.

And, Cross is BORING. Man, when we've got Ed McBain, Ian Rankin, John Harvey, Elmore Leonard, and PD James, why would we ever want to read Patterson?

-- posted by shelfmonkey


Post this Discussion Post to facebook Add this Discussion Post to del.icio.us! Digg this Discussion Post furl this Discussion Post Add this Discussion Post to Reddit Add this Discussion Post to Technorati Add this Discussion Post to Newsvine Add this Discussion Post to Windows Live Add this Discussion Post to Yahoo Add this Discussion Post to StumbleUpon Add this Discussion Post to BlinkLists Add this Discussion Post to Spurl Add this Discussion Post to Google Add this Discussion Post to Ask Add this Discussion Post to Squidoo


Please follow the guidelines set forth in the Suite101 Posting Etiquette when adding to the discussion.